Free Ebook.


Enter your email address:

Delivered by

« Save Money by Exercising | Main | Feeling Poor Despite Good Earnings »

April 16, 2018

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Using retirement accounts as emergency funds is the worst thing one can do. People typically need emergency funds when the market is down, so they're selling their portfolio at a lower price than they should

Yes, borrowing from a 401k is risky business and should only be done in extreme financial situations. Use your emergency funds instead...You have some, right?

401k loans are not double taxed. These two scenarios are equivalent, except that the first takes a $5k loan.

The part most people miss, is that you get to use those funds that were put in tax free for an after tax purchase.

This is not going to paste well from Excel (whitespace removed), but I'm going to try anyway. You'll just need to align columns yourself when reading this.

Gross Earning 401k Deposits 401k Repay 20% Taxes Net Earnings Bank Inflows 401k Balance
Baseline $50k $10k $- $8k $32k $32k $10k
401k Loan $- $(5k) $- $- $5k $37k $5k
Next Annual Pay $50k $10k $5k $8k $27k $64k $20k
Retire $- $(20k) $- $4k $16k $80k $-
Sum of Taxes:$20k

Gross Earning 401k Deposits 401k Repay 20% Taxes Net Earnings Bank Inflows 401k Balance
Baseline $50k $10k $- $8k $32k $32k $10k
401k Loan $- $- $- $- $- $32k $10k
Next Annual Pay $50k $10k $- $8k $32k $64k $20k
Retire $- $(20k) $- $4k $16k $80k $-
Sum of Taxes:$20k

However - it's still fundamentally a bad idea to borrow from your retirement.

Taking money from 401k is something I would recommend the least. Even though the current financial troubles may be resolved with its help, the number of problems that follow may make the situation much worse.

I like the part where you explain in what situations borrowing from 401k is a good idea. I've met several people who didn't have another plan and this was the only way out. If you do it wisely, no dramatic harm will be done.

Do you know you can have a self directed IRA at say TDAmeritrade and control what securities you are invested in? A really true self directed IRA will allow your IRA to actually own a business and all of them money you do not pay yourself can go directly into the IRA it is very powerful as if you set up a true self directed Roth IRA you can put profits right into the IRA and never pay tax when you qualify for distribution.Here is one company that is a custodian STRATA Trust Company acts only as a passive custodian of self directed individual retirement accounts.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Start a Blog


Best Blogs

Top Blogs





























Disclaimer


  • Any information shared on Alltribes does not constitute financial advice. The Website is intended to provide general information only and does not attempt to give you advice that relates to your specific circumstances. You are advised to discuss your specific requirements with an independent financial adviser. Per FTC guidelines, this website may be compensated by companies mentioned through advertising, affiliate programs or otherwise. All posts are © 2005-2012, Alltribes.

Stats